News

The false promise of league restructuring

Rod Lyall 28/01/24

The siren-call of grade inflation is once again being heard in Dutch cricket.

For those who don’t know, grade inflation is the process by which students are given higher marks than their work justifies in order to make them feel better and to make it look as if the system is stronger than it is.

Its cricketing form is currently circulating in relation to the Dutch competition, where a group of clubs led by Salland are pushing for a restructuring which would double the number of pools in the Overgangsklasse (really the fourth division) from two to four, or from 16 teams to 32.

Not content with this, the proponents of the scheme are proposing that the third division (a.k.a. the Eerste Klasse) should be doubled from ten teams to 20 from 2025, with the Overgangsklasse then renamed the Tweede Klasse.

The effect of all this is to push teams which are not good enough to gain promotion by their own efforts on the field up the competition tree, so that they have the illusion that they are playing at a higher level when in fact all they are doing is lowering the overall standard.

It was a mistake which was made by the previous Board – full disclosure, of which I was a member – in 2016 when, against all advice from players and senior administrators, it increased the number of teams in the Topklasse from eight to ten.

The argument then was that it would relieve clubs’ fear of relegation, that it would encourage bringing more young players into sides, and that it would, feeding down the divisions, enable clubs to claim that they were playing at a higher level than they otherwise would have been.

But the truth is that it reduced the playing standard in the top divisions, and with a few notable exceptions, it has not increased clubs’ willingness to develop younger sides – you only had to watch last year’s Hoofdklasse final between Hermes-DVS and Quick Haag to register how few promising young players they have been able to produce.

The bogus claim in the new proposals that they are needed to enable talented cricketers to play at their true level conveniently ignores the fact that the KNCB has for decades operated a promotion-and-relegation system which means that if a team is good enough it can work its way up the divisions.

And that now goes double, with the separation last year of the promotion-and-relegation systems for 50-over and T20 cricket, which already meant that different sides (Salland and ACC respectively) dropped down to this season’s Hoofdklasse in the two formats.

So what is to be gained by elevating half the teams in last season’s Tweede Klasse into a new-look, four-pool Overgangsklasse?

Would Pool C, for example, really be stronger for the presence of Centurions 2, Kampong 4 and Salland 2, none of whom was able to finish higher than fourth in their Tweede Klasse group last year?

And what is the benefit to anyone, including the teams themselves, of saving from relegation Den Helder, Zwolle, Olympia and Wanica Star, all of whom finished bottom of their pools in last season’s Tweede Klasse?

The one positive thing which can be said about the scheme is that more teams in a division means that the pools can be structured to reduce travelling times, which is no inconsiderable factor in the lower levels of recreational cricket, which is, to be honest, what we’re talking about here.

Domestic cricket competitions in serious cricket nations – which, for the sake of argument, let us suppose the Netherlands to be – serve two purposes: they enable as many people as possible to enjoy a regular game of cricket at the appropriate level for their talent and skills, and they provide a framework for the most talented players to hone their skills, equipping them for the step up to the international stage.

It’s a fair question whether the Dutch domestic competition does the latter at all well.

Yes, more locally-produced players have made the grade recently than for a few years, with the likes of Bas de Leede, Vikram Singh and Aryan Dutt establishing themselves successfully in the national team, but overall the Topklasse competition contains too few local players of genuine quality to sustain ten teams: Salland were able to stay up for as long as they did by shipping in German internationals, other clubs have drawn in talent from Belgium, and still the average number of players capable of achieving a modest average of 20.00 with the bat or 25.00 with the ball is about eight per team.

That means that there are 30 or so players in the Topklasse every week who are basically making up the numbers, and it’s not as if there battalions of young cricketers in lower-division clubs being prevented from joining their ranks.

An ideal structure is a pyramid, attuned to the amount of talent available: in the Netherlands, with barely 2000 adult male players, that would probably be three top divisions of eight, two fourth-division pools of eight, and below that divisions of perhaps four pools, geographically organised as far as possible.

Roughly the system, in other words, we had between 2011 and 2016, before the Board listened to the siren’s first haunting cries.

Oh, and to that a sensible governing body would add a proper regional competition of, say, three teams, enabling the best players to strut their stuff in contests tougher than most matches in the club league are capable of being.

But one thing should be absolutely clear: you can’t turn a broom cupboard into a splendid dining room by changing the label on the door, all you do is re-emphasise the fact that it’s a broom cupboard.

Edwards, O’Dowd and Rutgers move to Kampong

Rod Lyall 17/11/23

The Topklasse will be the poorer for the loss of national team captain Scott Edwards and opener Max O’Dowd following the announcement from Hoofdklasse club Kampong Utrecht that the pair, along with Spanish national coach Corey Rutgers will be leaving VOC Rotterdam and playing at Maarschalkerweerd.

Edwards made 509 runs for the Bloodhounds last season at an average of 50.90, while O’Dowd contributed 482 at 43.82, 186 of them in one brutal early-season innings against ACC.

In all, O’Dowd has made 3455 runs in 90 matches for VOC at an average of 45.46, including seven centuries, and Edwards 2671 at 46.86 in 76 games, with three hundreds.

They will leave a significant gap in the Rotterdammers’ top order, which it will not be easy to fill; even with them in the side the batting has tended to show signs of brittleness under pressure, and the side finished sixth in last season’s championship play-off.

For Kampong, on the other hand, the arrival of the two international stars will seriously strengthen their challenge for promotion to the Topklasse in 2025.

They were widely seen as somewhat unfortunate to be relegated from the twelve-team Topklasse in 2022, and they finished a creditable fourth in the Hoofklasse last season.

Edwards and O’Dowd will join national A-squad players Alex Roy and Pierre Jacod and under-18 seamer Gert Swanepoel at Maarschalkerweerd, and while they will miss parts of what promises to be another busy season because of their national team commitments, they are likely to cause plenty of headaches for opposing attacks in the matches they do play.

In statements on the Kampong website all three players stress the family-friendly atmosphere, the facilities and the ambitions of the Utrecht club, which (like VOC) boasts a turf square and hosts matches of the national men’s and women’s teams.

Topklasse Team of the Year 2023

Rod Lyall & Bertus de Jong 04/09/23


RL:  Once again it’s time for us to select our Topklasse Team of the Year. This year we need to specify that the selection is based on performances in the 50-over competition, and once again we will restrict ourselves to two overseas players in the eleven. So, first the openers. Voorburg’s Michael Levitt certainly stands out, with four centuries in his 655 runs, including a fine 102 in the grand final, and there’s a strong case, too, for Vikram Singh of VRA, although it’s true that 155 of his 548 runs came in one extraordinary innings at Craeyenhout. Still, he did make two other hundreds, and on his day he is capable of destroying an attack like nobody else in the Dutch game. Max O’Dowd (VOC), another brutal batterer of bowling, had a comparatively quiet season by his high standards after hammering 186 against ACC, and another honourable mention should go to Shirase Rasool, often Singh’s opening partner at VRA. But I’d go with Levitt and Singh.

Tayo Walbrugh

BdJ: A fair shout I’d say, in what’s otherwise been a comparatively lean summer for openers the two youngsters certainly stand out. Another shout out is probably due Ratha Alphonse, who played some more than useful innings at the top of the order for his new club, but the numbers aren’t there for him to challenge Singh or Levitt. Fair to say they benefit from Tayo Walbrugh having dropped down the order for HBS, as have the Crows themselves – to the tune of almost 1,000 runs. With 988 at 61.75 Walbrugh topped the runs table by a distance, with Sparta’s Garnet Tarr more than 200 runs behind in second place. Both merit a place in the team of the year top order for my money, even at the cost of both of our overseas slots. Walbrugh’s weight of runs simply can’t be ignored, while Tarr taking the gloves for much of Sparta’s season  saves us an otherwise tricky discussion on the subject of wicketkeepers.

Unless they’re secretly holding Dutch passports, that leaves room for neither VRA’s Johan Smal nor VOC’s Lane Berry, though both comfortably broke the 600-run mark this season. By the same token, ACC’s Heino Kuhn is ruled out despite being in large part responsible for the club’s mid-table finish in what was looking a tough year. Conversely, Voorburg’s Sybrand Engelbrecht is overseas no longer, and his return of 549 runs at 54.9 (coupled with the small matter of captaining his side to the title) certainly gives him a strong claim. Punjab’s Shoaib Minhas and Mohammad Riaz both also finished the season with 50+ averages, but to my mind finished it rather too soon to be considered for inclusion here. If one were minded to include another specialist bat then a case might be made for Scott Edwards, who racked up 509 runs at almost a run-a-ball, or perhaps for VCC’s Musa Ahmad, though his best returns have come in the shorter format this year. I’d be more inclined to go with a genuine all-rounder at here though, and Saqib Zulfiqar’s 534 runs at 44.5 are more than enough to warrant a place in the top six even before considering his 29 wickets.

RL: A top six of Singh, Levitt, Walbrugh, Tarr, Engelbrecht and Saqib Zulfiqar works for me. If we’re going to slip our keeper in as a top-order batter, though, I’d also want to give a shout-out to Voorburg’s Noah Croes, whose 18 catches and seven stumpings was a not inconsiderable factor in their success. (I’d acknowledge, however, that a bowling unit like Voorburg’s is bound to be healthy for any keeper’s statistics.)  If we have room for a bowling all-rounder at number seven, then the choice seems to me to lie between Hidde Overdijk, whose 32 wickets at 20.62 made a big contribution to HCC’s reaching another grand final and who also averaged 24.42 with the bat, and Sikander Zulfiqar of Punjab, who only took 18 wickets but who made 411 runs at 41.10 and played several very significant knocks to keep his side in contention longer than they might otherwise have been. Forced to choose, I’d go for Overdijk, but I’d be happier still if we could find room for both.

Saqib Zulfiqar

BdJ: I’d hesitate to call Sikander a bowling all-rounder at this point, given he’s generally occupied the number four spot for Punjab this season, and while 18 scalps is a decent tally those wickets have come at an average of almost 30 and an economy rate over a run a ball. If we were to go looking for another seam bowling all-rounder, I’d say that Kyle Klein, whose contributions with both bat and ball have been indispensible for HBS, arguably has the strongest case after Overdijk, though not an overwhelming one.

Turning to to the spinners, one name comes pre-printed on the sheet. With 47 wickets at 10.66 Voorburg’s googly-merchant Shariz Ahmad has been instrumental in their title run, his wrist-spin partnership with the more conventional Philippe Boissevain crucial to their near-perfect run through the competition. With Saqib Zulfiqar already inked in there’s little room for another leggie, but two left armers do  stand out among the finger spinners for their parsimony. The evergreen Lorenzo Ingram bowled 120 overs for Excelsior at the cost of just just 383 runs and claimed 26 wickets into the bargain, yet the veteran has been eclipsed this year by fellow West Indian Daniel Doram, the Sint Maartener taking one more wicket while matching Ingram’s economy of 3.13. Right arm off-spinners have had tougher time this season, with the notable exception of VOC’s Arnav Jain. Despite struggling with a shoulder injury Jain took 23 wickets opening the bowling for VOC at an average of just 16 while going for just 3.5 an over, head and shoulders above rival right arm tweakers.

Martijn Snoep

RL:  I’m not sure that Ingram, despite his long and distinguished service with Excelsior, doesn’t still count as overseas, but I completely agree that Doram, in a very different way from Shariz, has been a stand-out spinner this season. If we include these two spinners and Overdijk as a fast-bowling all-rounder, we have two places left for specialist pace bowlers. Voorburg’s Ryan Klein only played 12 matches, but he claimed 27 wickets at 11.56, with a strike rate of 17.93 (second only to Shariz among the regular bowlers) and an economy rate of 3.87. Who should join him is a tougher call: Ahsan Malik and Khalid Ahmadi of Sparta were excellent before the break but did not reappear after it, and, as Bertus noted earlier, Kyle Klein’s 21 wickets at 27.24 don’t constitute an overwhelming argument even when his batting is taken into account. My inclination would be to go for one of the genuine servants of the domestic game in Sparta’s excellent captain, Joost Martijn Snoep, who took 22 wickets at 19.23, with an economy rate of 3.63. In the absence of Malik and Ahmadi and Mudassar Bukhari struggling with injury, he bore much of the burden as well as proving a dogged number eleven with the bat.

BdJ: Well it seems we find ourselves in furious agreement here. In light of expectations at the start of the season, coupled with the difficulties posed by the unavailabilities and injuries that dogged  the Spartan seam section, I’d argue that Snoep leading his side to a top-four finish is a more impressive accomplishment than Voorburg’s deservedly claiming the silverware, and one that warrants the armband this year for Sparta’s skipper-chair. With ball in hand he was not only Sparta’s lead wicket-taker, but also the second most economical seamer in the competition behind only VCC’s Vivian Kingma who deserves a mention here as the only quick to go at less than 3.5 an over this season. At the other extreme we’d be remiss not to make some mention of Eduard Visser’s tally of 31 wickets, second best of the seamers and third overall behind only Overdijk and Ahmad by that metric, but the 752-run price tag attached puts him behind Klein for mine too, even before considering the latter’s title-sealing performance in the Grand Final.

RL: So, TKcricket’s Topklasse Team of the Year is:

Vikram Singh (VRA), Michael Levitt (Voorburg), Tayo Walbrugh (HBS), Garnett Tarr (Sparta), Sybrand Engelbrecht (Voorburg), Saqib Zulfiqar (Punjab), Hidde Overdijk (HCC), Shariz Ahmad (Voorburg), Ryan Klein (Voorburg), Daniel Doram (HCC), and Joost-Martijn Snoep (Sparta, captain).
12th man: Arnav Jain


Previous TOTYs | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018

Hermes and Quick lock horns in final promotion battle

Rod Lyall 01/09/23

If the semi-final between Hermes-DVS and Quick Haag fortnight ago is any guide, then the Hoofdklasse grand final at Sportpark Harga on Saturday, which will determine which of the two sides returns to the Topklasse next season, should be a cracker.

Then it took a Nick Statham boundary off the final ball of the match to decide the outcome, Hermes winning by one wicket, and across the two formats the teams have been evenly matched all season, Hermes having won three of their five head-to-head meetings and Quick two.

Hermes have already secured a place in next year’s Topklasse T20 Cup, having beaten their rivals fairly comfortably in the final, and will be out to make it a double on Saturday.

Leading the charge will be two of their three overseas players: 19-year-old South African Ashley Ostling, the side’s leading run-scorer with 567 at an average of 43.62, and Spanish international Daniel Doyle Calle; New Zealander Will Hamilton is injured and will take no part.

But Quick’s attack will still need to contain Ostling and Doyle effectively if they are to have a realistic chance of taking the title and earning promotion.

Quick, though, have two outstanding overseas players of their own, not least Otago’s left-handed opener Cameron Jackson, whose 164-ball 223 last week snuffed out Kampong Utrecht’s hopes of making it to the grand final.

Jackson leads the Hoofdklasse batting aggregates with 890 runs at 68.46, closely followed by team-mate Beckham Wheeler Greenall with 768 at 69.82.

If the Hermes trio are crucial to their side’s chances, Jackson and Wheeler Greenall are scarcely less so for Quick, and early wickets will be vital in both innings.

One somewhat disturbing feature of the match is how little Dutch-produced young talent will be on display: of Hermes’ likely squad six were in the club’s side in or before their most recent appearance in the Topklasse in 2017, while in Quick’s case eight had played before their relegation in 2019.

The Father of the Hermes team is 48-year-old Statham, who made his top-flight debut in 1989 and who has notched up 11,175 runs in his 482 matches, while his opposite number at Quick is fellow former international Henk Mol, two years younger, with 7352 runs and 413 wickets in 365 games.

Mol is still taking wickets, his tally of 20 this season just one behind that of Quick’s leading wicket-taker Jeroen Brand, but the top wicket-taker in the competition is Hermes’ Sahil Kothari with 29.

With Dutch A-team captain Sebastiaan Braat – who also skippers the side – and brothers Olivier and Ralph Elenbaas in the attack, backed up by Roy Numair and Davey Verweij, Hermes probably have the more incisive bowling unit.

As against that, alongside Jackson and Wheeler Greenall Quick’s batting line-up includes skipper Daan Vierling, Lesley Stokkers, Bobby van Gigch, allrounder Brand and perhaps Henk Mol’s brother Geert Maarten, totalling close to a thousand top-flight matches between them, so there will be no lack of experience on either side.

Having taken the Hoofdklasse title last year, when there was no promotion to the Topklasse, Hermes have a point to prove, while Quick’s demolition of Kampong last week indicates that the Schiedammers are unlikely to have things all their own way.

Scorecard | VCC vs HCC | 26.08.23

Voorburg I Vs HCC I
1-Innings Match Played At Westvliet, Voorburg, 26-Aug-2023, Topklasse
Voorburg I Win by 140 runs
Round GF
Toss won by Voorburg I
Umpires NR Bathi – WPM van Liemt – M Prabhudesai
Scorers CC Schinkel – K Pattiselanno
Home Side Voorburg I
Points Awarded Voorburg I 2, HCC I 0
Voorburg I 1st Innings 295/7 Closed (Overs 50)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
ML Levitt   b DT Doram 102 119 12 1
N Gigani   b HC Overdijk 4 7 1 0
MN Ahmad c C Floyd b P Charumbira 78 106 6 1
NRJ Croes+ c P Charumbira b HC Overdijk 36 27 3 0
SA Engelbrecht* lbw b DT Doram 20 10 2 1
S Ahmad c P Charumbira b C Floyd 8 11 0 0
R Klein   c&b HC Overdijk 24 14 2 1
GK Nieuwoudt not out   9 6 0 0
PRP Boissevain not out   1 1 0 0
VJ Kingma dnb          
MC van Vliet dnb          
extras   (b0 lb3 w9 nb1) 13      
TOTAL   7 wickets for 295      
FOW
1-12(N Gigani) 2-195(MN Ahmad) 3-201(ML Levitt) 4-223(SA Engelbrecht) 5-237(S Ahmad) 6-263(NRJ Croes) 7-290(R Klein)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
HC Overdijk 10 0 78 3 2
DD Crowley 7 0 38 0 2
H Venter 8 0 30 0 4
C Floyd 10 0 60 1 1
DT Doram 10 1 49 2 1
P Charumbira 5 0 37 1
HCC I 1st Innings 155/10 All Out (Overs 38.3)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
JD Vandiar c SA Engelbrecht b VJ Kingma 7 20 1 0
AJ Staal c MN Ahmad b R Klein 36 52 4 1
MR Alphonse+   b R Klein 8 33 0 0
BHG Gorlee* c NRJ Croes b R Klein 39 47 2 0
TP Kloppenburg   b S Ahmad 3 7 0 0
C Floyd   b VJ Kingma 19 32 2 0
HC Overdijk st NRJ Croes b S Ahmad 24 21 3 0
P Charumbira   b R Klein 0 1 0 0
DT Doram not out   5 14 0 0
DD Crowley   b R Klein 0 4 0 0
H Venter   b R Klein 0 1 0 0
extras   (b1 lb7 w5 nb1) 14      
TOTAL   10 wickets for 155      
FOW
1-22(JD Vandiar) 2-56(MR Alphonse) 3-63(AJ Staal) 4-70(TP Kloppenburg) 5-116(C Floyd) 6-142(BHG Gorlee) 7-142(P Charumbira) 8-154(HC Overdijk) 9-155(DD Crowley) 10-155(H Venter)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
VJ Kingma 7 1 27 2 1
GK Nieuwoudt 8 2 39 0 1 1
R Klein 7.3 0 15 6 2
MC van Vliet 6 0 23 0 1
S Ahmad 6 0 24 2
PRP Boissevain 4 0 19 0

VCC vs HCC at Westvliet | Grand Final | 26.08.23

Voorburg power their way to the title

Rod Lyall 27/08/23

Those who came to Westvliet on Saturday anticipating a close finish or a repeat of last year’s upset HCC victory went away disappointed, but there was no doubt about the home club’s elation as Voorburg simply steamrollered their way to their first championship win in twenty-one years, and the second in their history.

There was, though, no shortage of skill on display, not least from the ground staff, who after heavy rain in the early morning worked like Trojans to get the ground ready for an 11 o’clock start.

There were, it is true, a few moments in the opening overs when the defending champions could have thought that Voorburg skipper’s Sybrand Engelbrecht’s decision to bat first might misfire.

Hidde Overdijk bowled Nehaan Gigani in the third over, his 200th Topklasse wicket, and with the pitch showing early signs of vertical inconsistency as well as lateral movement, Michael Levitt and Musa Ahmad were beaten several times, Levitt at one point, immediately after unleashing a back-foot cover drive off Overdijk which probably remained the shot of the day, hazardously edging the bowler between keeper and first slip.

But the batters gradually took control, their partnership steadily mounting, and it would be the 38th over before HCC succeeded in breaking through again, by which time Levitt and Musa had put on 183 and the former had reached his fourth century of the season.

It was Musa who was the first to go, cutting at Patient Charumbira and well caught by Clayton Floyd at point, who knocked the ball upwards and took it at the second attempt; Musa had made 78 from 106 deliveries and hit six fours and a six.

The six had come off Daniel Doram, a potential match-winner for HCC, and that blow and the four which followed next ball had forced skipper Boris Gorlee to pull the tall left-arm spinner out of the attack.

He returned as soon as Musa had gone, however, and with the first ball of the next over bowled Levitt for a 119-ball 102, which had included twelve fours and a six.

Two wickets in seven balls must have given the Lions some hope, but it was quickly snuffed out by Engelbrecht, who contributed a 10-ball cameo of 20 before he was trapped in front by Doram, and by Noah Croes, whose 36 ensured that the total kept motoring towards 300.

Although he was eventually caught by Charumbira off Overdijk, 50 runs came from the last five overs, Ryan Klein adding 24 of them before skying a return catch to Overdijk, and the innings closed on a very imposing 295 for seven.

Overdijk’s three wickets had come at a cost of 78, while Doram picked up two for 49, Henrico Venter was the most economical of the HCC attack, his eight wicketless overs costing just 30 runs.

It was a demanding chase against a Voorburg bowling unit which included four internationals, and Viv Kingma and Karl Nieuwoudt gave little away in their opening exchanges with Jonathan Vandiar and Tonny Staal.

The decisive moment came when Vandiar, who had just creamed Kingma for four through extra cover in his first real sign of aggression, clipped the next delivery hard to short midwicket, where Engelbrecht took a superb low catch.

Staal and Ratha Alphonse added 34 before Klein bowled Alphonse, and in his next over the paceman removed the other main threat, Staal pulling him down the throat of Musa on the midwicket boundary and departing for 36.

That pretty much pricked HCC’s balloon, and when Shariz Ahmad came into the attack and almost immediately bowled Teun Kloppenburg, Voorburg were well on their way to a comprehensive victory.

Gorlee, assisted by Clayton Floyd, continued to resist, but with boundary opportunities few and far between the asking rate began its inexorable rise, and soon HCC were needing in excess of eight an over to have any chance of turning the game around.

Eventually Kingma returned to bowl Floyd, but it was left to Klein, bowling full, fast and straight, to finish things off, dismissing Gorlee and Charumbira with successive deliveries and then, after a brief flourish by Overdijk which ended when he was well stumped by Croes off Shariz, repeated the trick by bowling first Crowley and then Venter, to end the innings on 155.

Klein finished with a career-best six for 15, while Shariz’s two for 24 brought his tally for the season to a remarkable 47 wickets at an even more remarkable average of 10.66.

As if this were not enough, Voorburg’s women’s team, after being bowled out for 87, dismissed Quick Haag for 75, Dutch international Eva Lynch taking five for 9, making Voorburg the first club since Kampong Utrecht in 1992 to win both the men’s and women’s titles in the same year.

A thrilling grand final in prospect

Rod Lyall 25/08/23

Back at the start of the season, much of the talk was about the formidable squad which Voorburg had assembled, and with just one defeat in 14 50-over matches last year’s beaten grand finalists have fully lived up to that billing.

For defending champions HCC, however, 2023 seemed likely to be a season of rebuilding, with half of their side from last year unavailable, and it is remarkable that after a shaky start to their campaign they have again reached the grand final, peaking at just the right time and giving themselves a real chance of winning the title from fourth position on the table.

The Lions have momentum on their side, but any grand final comes down to how the two sides perform on the day; how, then, do the squads stack up against one another?

The Voorburg pace attack against the HCC top order

With current internationals Viv Kingma and Ryan Klein, backed up by the up-and-coming Mees van Vliet and the steady medium pace of Karl Nieuwoudt – who often shares the new ball with Kingma – Voorburg have plenty of quicker options, none of the four having gone for more than five an over across the whole campaign.

Kingma may only have nine wickets so far, but he has the best strike rate of anyone in the side, and he has a proven ability to dismiss good batters inside the initial powerplay.

For HCC, the arrival of Ratha Alphonse has been a real bonus, his 386 runs at 32.17 having compensated to a considerable degree for the fact that Tonny Staal has had a relatively quiet season by his standards, averaging just 15.94.

In Alphonse’s absence in the play-off phase, however, the Lions have experimented with Jonathan Vandiar as an opening partner for Staal, Alphonse slotting in at three, and it will be interesting to see who opens on Saturday.

Vandiar’s innings against Punjab in the qualifying final was a model of restraint, but there is an argument that he is at his most effective at four or five, when his attacking instincts can be given full reign.

The top five is completed by captain Boris Gorlee and by sixteen-year-old Teun Kloppenburg, the latter having strung together three consecutive half-centuries in his first Topklasse season; if Vandiar does drop down the order, he and Kloppenburg have the potential to capitalise on any platform that Alphonse, Staal and Gorlee have been able to build.

The HCC pace attack against the Voorburg top order

Hidde Overdijk and Daniel Crowley have been in awesome form in their most recent games, reducing Sparta to 25 for four in the initial powerplay and putting Punjab under sustained pressure in the qualifier, and Overdijk’s 29 wickets at 20.07 puts him in equal third place among the leading wicket-takers.

There are, perhaps, more questions about the change bowling, with Henrico Venter and Patient Charumbira among the more expensive of the regular seam bowlers, although both have also been able to pick up valuable wickets; they have, though, been deployed later in the innings than Klein and Van Vliet have for Voorburg.

With a top five who all average 30 (or in Musa Ahmad’s case, just a tad short of it), Voorburg have a formidable line-up, but on closer inspection those stats are a little less encouraging: having made 456 runs at 57 in the first phase, Michael Levitt has added only 97 at 16.17 since the competition resumed and Noah Croes, too, has been less dominant in the back end.

Against that, Musa has made more runs in six innings since the break than he did in nine before it, and the transformation in skipper Sybrand Engelbrecht’s form has been even more dramatic: only Tayo Walbrugh made more runs in July and August than Engelbrecht’s 333.

All in all, then, the ability of Overdijk and Crowley to make early inroads into that imposing Voorburg top order may be one of the factors on which this year’s title depends.

Voorburg’s spinners against the HCC middle order

The most interesting battles of the day, however, may come when Engelbrecht and Gorlee turn to their slower bowlers.

With 45 wickets so far, Shariz Ahmad just needs what would be his fifth five-for of the season to become the first player since Chris Pringle in 1996 to take fifty wickets in a season, and it would come as little surprise if he did it; few batters have been able to get on top of him all year.

While his fellow wrist-spinner Philippe Boissevain has had a more modest return with 17 wickets at 21.59, he makes an outstanding foil for the young googly bowler, and they can be expected to cause plenty of problems in the middle overs.

Who’s at the crease when they come on will depend, of course, on how successful Voorburg’s quicker bowlers have been, and there could be a fascinating contest between their wiles and the aggression of Vandiar and Kloppenburg.

Beyond that, the HCC middle order of Clayton Floyd, Overdijk and Charumbira will need all their wits about them if they are to make a significant contribution to their side’s total.

HCC’s spinners against the Voorburg middle order

As against Voorburg’s wrist spinners, the Lions have two left-arm finger spinners, of whom late signing Daniel Doram has been distinctly the more effective with 27 wickets at 15.04 apiece.

His figures in the last two games of 10 – 6 – 4 – 1 and 9.2 – 2 – 14 – 4 were truly remarkable, and if he can manage something of the same order on Saturday it could be a game-changer.

Floyd has had a less successful campaign, but like Boissevain he provides outstanding support for Doram when the two are bowling in tandem, and his reliability means that Gorlee can use seamers Venter and Charumbira more sparingly.

Their battle with the Voorburg middle order, again, will be a key feature of the game, and of the later batters only Shariz, with 261 runs, has a comparable record to that of Floyd, Overdijk and Charumbira, although it must be said that the dominance of the top five has given them relatively few opportunities.

It’s all shaping up for a memorable contest, one that is, as election-night commentators say, too close to call. All this, and a chance to see the World Cup trophy as well!

Scorecard | Salland vs HBS | 19.07.23

Salland I Vs HBS I
1-Innings Match Played At Het Schootsveld, Deventer, 19-Aug-2023, Topklasse
HBS I Win by 108 runs
Round R/5
Toss won by Salland I
Umpires JE Hilhorst – N Uduwage
Home Side Salland I
Points Awarded HBS I 2, Salland I 0
HBS I 1st Innings 217/6 Closed (Overs 50)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
RP Mason run out   5 20 0 0
K Klein c RA Lubbers b A Gopinath 77 113 4 0
T Walbrugh c V Ganesan b A Gopinath 84 103 9 0
W Barresi* lbw b A Gopinath 6 7 1 0
NCW Adendorff c VS Lubbers b SV Elam Bharathi 12 25 1 0
JL de Mey lbw b A Gopinath 4 5 0 0
A Khan not out   12 15 1 0
E Boendermaker not out   9 12 1 0
BFL Boddendijk dnb          
MMR Scholte+ dnb          
YSK Visée dnb          
extras   (b2 lb0 w6 nb0) 8      
TOTAL   6 wickets for 217      
FOW
1-23(RP Mason) 2-162(T Walbrugh) 3-178(W Barresi) 4-179(K Klein) 5-188(JL de Mey) 6-197(NCW Adendorff)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
RA Lubbers 3 0 10 0
FC Bartholomew 6 0 25 0 3
SV Elam Bharathi 9 0 50 1
A Gopinath 10 0 41 4
V Ganesan 10 0 43 0 2
A Sherzad 5 0 18 0
G van der Molen 5 0 21 0 1
VS Lubbers 2 0 7 0
Salland I 1st Innings 109/9 All Out (Overs 27.1)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
V Ganesan   b NCW Adendorff 20 18 2 0
PP Ottachchige+ c MMR Scholte b JL de Mey 0 1 0 0
S Naqash c W Barresi b NCW Adendorff 31 33 5 1
VS Lubbers* c MMR Scholte b K Klein 9 19 1 0
A Sherzad run out BFL Boddendijk   1 11 0 0
FC Bartholomew c MMR Scholte b YSK Visée 7 16 1 0
G van der Molen c W Barresi b K Klein 2 5 0 0
RA Lubbers c T Walbrugh b BFL Boddendijk 0 4 0 0
SV Elam Bharathi c T Walbrugh b JL de Mey 15 23 1 0
A Gopinath not out   14 33 0 0
FP Raxworthy Absent          
extras   (b0 lb1 w9 nb0) 10      
TOTAL   9 wickets for 109      
FOW
1-7(PP Ottachchige) 2-42(V Ganesan) 3-55(S Naqash) 4-65(A Sherzad) 5-65(VS Lubbers) 6-73(G van der Molen) 7-74(RA Lubbers) 8-74(FC Bartholomew) 9-108(SV Elam Bharathi)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
NCW Adendorff 6 0 28 2 4
JL de Mey 3.1 0 28 2
K Klein 5 1 10 2
BFL Boddendijk 3 0 8 1
YSK Visée 3 1 9 1 1
A Khan 5 1 12 0 3
E Boendermaker 2 0 13 0 1

Scorecard | VRA vs Excelsior | 19.07.23

VRA I Vs Excelsior 20 I
1-Innings Match Played At Amstelveen (VRA), 19-Aug-2023, Topklasse
VRA I Win by 3 wkts
Round R/5
Toss won by VRA I
Umpires D Das – A Deshpande
Scorers KA Holdsworth – EM Heggelman
Home Side VRA I
Points Awarded Excelsior 20 I 0, VRA I 2
Excelsior 20 I 1st Innings 169/9 Closed (Overs 50)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
LA Kroesen c MDS Peiris b Aaditt Jain 8 14 1 0
MN Hart   c&b LA Turmaine 28 56 3 0
RTF Verhagen run out U Nashier/AT Nidamanuru   1 2 0 0
SL van Troost+ c SR Rasool b LA Turmaine 35 81 3 1
LT Ingram* lbw b LA Turmaine 12 19 1 0
TJ Heggelman run out MDS Peiris   56 87 4 2
S Butt c Aaditt Jain b A Dutt 12 29 1 0
SG Shankar c J Smal b A Dutt 2 7 0 0
RWA van Troost run out AT Nidamanuru/TJ van Luin   1 3 0 0
UF Baker not out   1 2 0 0
JJ Blankestijn dnb          
extras   (b0 lb2 w11 nb0) 13      
TOTAL   9 wickets for 169      
FOW
1-23(LA Kroesen) 2-24(RTF Verhagen) 3-67(MN Hart) 4-88(LT Ingram) 5-102(SL van Troost) 6-132(S Butt) 7-146(SG Shankar) 8-159(RWA van Troost) 9-169(TJ Heggelman)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
Aaditt Jain 4 0 16 1 1
E Visser 9 0 48 0 3
A Dutt 10 4 17 2
V Singh 5 0 13 0
LA Turmaine 10 1 28 3
TJ van Luin 6 0 28 0 3
U Nashier 6 1 17 0
VRA I 1st Innings 172/7 (Overs 40.2)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
SR Rasool c SL van Troost b JJ Blankestijn 25 32 2 1
TJ van Luin   b MN Hart 0 2 0 0
J Smal c LA Kroesen b RTF Verhagen 50 74 3 2
AT Nidamanuru lbw b JJ Blankestijn 2 5 0 0
A Dutt c SL van Troost b JJ Blankestijn 1 17 0 0
U Nashier c RTF Verhagen b UF Baker 26 51 2 0
MDS Peiris+ c LT Ingram b UF Baker 14 32 0 0
LA Turmaine not out   13 20 0 0
E Visser not out   7 10 1 0
Aaditt Jain dnb          
V Singh* dnb          
extras   (b5 lb6 w22 nb1) 34      
TOTAL   7 wickets for 172      
FOW
1-3(TJ van Luin) 2-58(SR Rasool) 3-63(AT Nidamanuru) 4-69(A Dutt) 5-113(J Smal) 6-136(U Nashier) 7-153(MDS Peiris)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
MN Hart 6 0 28 1 4
TJ Heggelman 4 0 22 0 2
JJ Blankestijn 5 0 23 3 5
LT Ingram 6 2 16 0
RTF Verhagen 6 1 17 1 4
UF Baker 8.2 0 29 2
RWA van Troost 5 0 26 0 3 1