Player-eligibility technicality puts VRA’s T20 finals berth in doubt

Bertus de Jong 10/09/2025


Defeated semi-finalists Voorburg CC, who lost to VRA by 22 runs in the second semi-final of the Topklasse T20 competition on Sunday, are seeking to have the result of that match overturned on grounds that VRA fielded an ineligible player. VCC are understood to have challenged the eligibility of VRA opening bat Shirase Rasool – who scored a brisk 41 before retiring hurt in the match in question – on the basis that he had not played sufficient matches in the preceding league phase.

Shirase Rasool

Rasool, a former regular at the top of the order for VRA, has played only intermittently this season owing to personal commitments. In total Rasool has made three appearances for VRA’s second team and five for the senior side this season, but crucially played only four matches in the T20 competition.

Under Article 18 of the Competitieregelement only players that have played a minimum of 50% of the first (league) stage matches of the T20 competition are eligible to participate in the final rounds. Under the current competition format the minimum is thus five matches in across divisions prior to the finals phase; Rasool therefore falling one match short.

However, a number of exemptions to these requirements are detailed in the same document, not least 18.II.7.b which exempts long-standing members of a club from the above participation requirements, under which Voorburg match-secretary and first team occasional Floris de Lange was able to play. VRA maintains that Rasool is similarly exempt under Articles 18.II.6 and 18.II.7.b, which provides for players who have regularly played for a club in preceding seasons, though the language of the document is arguably inconsistent as to whether this refers to all competition or exclusively divisions below the top flight.

“VRA is confident that we are fully within the regulations regarding the eligibility of Shirase Rasool. Articles 18.II.6 and 18.II.7 clearly state that he qualifies to play without needing to meet the five-match threshold or apply for dispensation. It is extremely disappointing how this situation has unfolded, as it distracts from the spirit of the competition and takes the focus away from the cricket itself.” VRA first team captain and General Manager Teja Nidamanuru told TKcricket.

Voorburg Chair Richard de Lange was equally confident however, stating; “VCC remains confident in the strength of our position and our rightful place in the T20 final based on the merits of our case and adherence to competition regulations. We respect the ongoing appeals process and trust that the proper procedures will ultimately ensure the integrity of the competition is upheld. We look forward to a swift and fair resolution that serves the best interests of cricket in the Netherlands.”

VRA immediately appealed the KNCB’s initial decision, which Tkcricket understands awarded the match and a place in the final to VCC and imposed a 100 euro fine on VRA. That appeal appears to have been at least initially successful in reversing the decision, but said reversal has duly been appealled in turn by VCC. At press time it remains unclear who, if anyone, HCC will face in Saturday’s final at the Loopuyt Oval.

2025 Preview 4: Voorburg and HCC

Rod Lyall 19/04/2025

Champions in 2024 and defeated semi-finalists last year, Voorburg will be delighted to welcome back South African Gavin Kaplan, who topped the season’s batting averages with 701 runs at 77.89, hitting four centuries and three fifties in just ten innings.

Given that he also chipped in with 15 wickets at 18.67, he had a strong claim to be the overseas player of the year, and there is no doubt that the Westvliet club missed him sorely in their last five games, when he had returned to South Africa.

He will be joined this year by two Zimbabweans, 30-year-old international Carl Mumba and former Under-19 international Patient Charumbira, the latter making the short journey from HCC.

Mumba, who played 19 times for Zimbabwe across the three formats between 2016 and 2021, will reinforce an already strong Voorburg pace attack, which includes Viv Kingma – whose appearances may well be limited by national team commitments – and the steadily-improving Mees van Vliet, even if fitness problems continue to make Ryan Klein a useful off-spinner rather than one of the competition’s most effective pace bowlers.

Charumbira, too, is a more than useful medium-pacer, as well as a hard-hitting lower order batter.

Another acquisition is 20-year-old Australian Henry Melville, who plays for Melbourne University in the Victorian Premier competition.

A wicketkeeper and useful middle-order bat, Melville will perhaps be competing for the gloves with young Cedric de Lange when skipper Noah Croes is absent on national team duty; gifted behind the stumps, De Lange’s batting showed signs of growing maturity last summer, and with a maiden Topklasse half-century behind him he will be looking to establish his place in the side.

Voorburg have also picked up former national Under-18 captain Udit Nashier, who moves to Westvliet from VRA, where he only bowled six overs of spin in the Topklasse last season and, notably, posted his maiden half-century against the club he is now joining.

The only departure is Stijn de Leede, who has decided to try his luck with Hoofdklasse club Quick Haag this season.

With Michael Levitt (when fit and available), Nehaan Gagani and Nirav Kulkarni in the batting line-up, and Laurens Boissevain and youngsters like Alejo Nota and Tom de Leede also in the squad, Voorburg have enviable strength in depth, which will likely be a crucial factor given the club’s strong representation in the national set-up.

Skipper Croes recognises that restricted availability creates uncertainties, but believes that his squad is strong enough to challenge for a place in the top four, and possibly even head the table in this year’s playoffless competition format.

‘It will be a really interesting year with a format which is very positive for Dutch cricket,’ he says, ‘and the exposure which our younger players gained last year will stand us in good stead.

‘It’s really cool that Gavin Kaplan is coming back, and Henry Melville is a genuine problem-solver, who will adapt well to changing playing surfaces.’


There are big changes at HCC, with none of last year’s three overseas back this year, and an influx of locally-based players to join a new brace of imports.

One of the latter is New Zealander Oliver White, who had the tricky task of replacing Kaplan at Voorburg at the end of last season, but is now back for a full campaign at De Diepput.

Now back with Northern Districts, where he started his career, the left-arm spinning allrounder will be joined at HCC by another member of the Northern Districts squad, South African-born pace bowler Josh Brown.

Brown has broken into ND’s Plunkett Shield side over the Southern Hemisphere summer, and will doubtless slot into the new-ball spot vacated by Adam Leonard.

Equally significant for HCC’s prospects, though, is likely to be the return of Clayton Floyd and Henrico Venter from VRA and HBS respectively: Floyd had a relatively quiet season with VRA last year, but HCC will be hoping that he can return to the sort of form which saw him claim 37 Topklasse wickets in 2021 at a cost of 7.32 apiece.

Venter, who last played for HCC in 2023, has accumulated 60 Topklasse wickets for his three clubs, but had limited opportunities at HBS last year and will be looking for a more significant role following his return to De Diepput.

Other arrivals include youngsters Mark Wolfe and Dinand van Hommel, transferring from ACC and Hermes-DVS respectively, and South African Jayden Peskin, who was Western Province CC’s Most Improved Player for the 2023/24 season.

These seven join the club’s established players, again led by Boris Gorlee, who like Tonny Staal enjoyed only intermittent success last year. Both will be looking to recover something of the form which took them into the Dutch national side a couple of years ago, and which contributed significantly to the side’s Topklasse championship run in 2023.

The same applies to the middle-order contribution with the bat by allrounder Hidde Overdijk, although he remains a very effective member of the pace attack, having claimed 15 wickets last year at 15.88.

Among the younger brigade, Teun Kloppenburg, after a very productive introduction to the top flight in which he hit three successive half-centuries, had a poor run towards the end of last season and will be looking to get back into his best form, and Shirsak Banerjee will also hope to consolidate his place in the top order.

Seamer Teun Leijer’s 17 wickets in his first season at De Diepput was a very promising start, and he will again form part of a traditionally-strong HCC seam attack, alongside Brown, Overdijk and Daniel Crowley, the leading wicket-taker last year with 22 at 25.27.

Scorecard | VCC vs VRA | 03.07.21

Voorburg I Vs VRA I
1-Innings Match Played At Westvliet, Voorburg, 03-Jul-2021, Topklasse
Voorburg I Win by 6 wkts
Round 12
Toss won by Voorburg I
Umpires S Bhagat – ML Hancock
Home Side Voorburg I
Points Awarded VRA I 0, Voorburg I 4
VRA I 1st Innings 178/10 All Out (Overs 46.5)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
V Singh lbw b GK Nieuwoudt 17 35 3 0
L Scully c M Hingorani b A Dutt 50 79 6 1
ES Szwarczynski   b BFW de Leede 55 80 6 0
PW Borren* c S Kamal b PRP Boissevain 17 33 0 0
J Balbirnie c M Hingorani b BFW de Leede 6 5 1 0
SR Rasool c M Hingorani b GK Nieuwoudt 9 11 1 0
MB Lees+ lbw b A Dutt 4 14 0 0
LA Turmaine   b PRP Boissevain 0 1 0 0
QWM Gunning lbw b PRP Boissevain 5 13 0 0
A Abid not out   4 9 0 0
L Hartsink   b PRP Boissevain 2 3 0 0
extras   (b4 lb1 w3 nb1) 9      
TOTAL   10 wickets for 178      
FOW
1-49(V Singh) 2-120(L Scully) 3-140(ES Szwarczynski) 4-150(J Balbirnie) 5-163(SR Rasool) 6-163(PW Borren) 7-164(LA Turmaine) 8-170(MB Lees) 9-172(QWM Gunning) 10-178(L Hartsink)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
BFW de Leede 9 3 30 2 1
GK Nieuwoudt 10 2 42 2 1
PRP Boissevain 8.5 0 38 4 1
ST Mulder 5 0 16 0
A Dutt 10 0 27 2
S Kamal 4 1 20 0 1
Voorburg I 1st Innings 182/4 (Overs 47.2)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
M Hingorani+ c MB Lees b A Abid 8 22 1 0
TN de Grooth c SR Rasool b A Abid 1 7 0 0
BFW de Leede* lbw b V Singh 24 43 3 0
SA Engelbrecht not out   59 96 6 0
A Dutt   c&b L Hartsink 41 58 3 1
GK Nieuwoudt not out   37 58 1 1
R Pieterse dnb          
VJ Kingma dnb          
PRP Boissevain dnb          
S Kamal dnb          
ST Mulder dnb          
extras   (b0 lb2 w10 nb0) 12      
TOTAL   4 wickets for 182      
FOW
1-4(TN de Grooth) 2-13(M Hingorani) 3-42(BFW de Leede) 4-116(A Dutt)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
QWM Gunning 8 0 38 0 4
A Abid 4 1 11 2
V Singh 8 0 32 1 6
LA Turmaine 8.2 1 41 0
PW Borren 10 2 19 0
L Hartsink 6 0 26 1
J Balbirnie 3 0 13 0

Scorecard | VOC vs VCC | 26.06.21

VOC I Vs Voorburg I
1-Innings Match Played At Hazelaarweg, Rotterdam, 26-Jun-2021, Topklasse
Voorburg I Win by 63 runs (DLS)
Round 11
Toss won by VOC I
Umpires R Mahabier – P Muthucumaru
Home Side VOC I
Comment Rain stopped play, Voorburg 120-1 (29.1 overs), DLS par score at 29.1 overs 57.
Points Awarded VOC I 0, Voorburg I 4
VOC I 1st Innings 136/10 All Out (Overs 40.3)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
SA Edwards+ c GK Nieuwoudt b BFW de Leede 3 14 0 0
MP O’Dowd c VJ Kingma b BFW de Leede 2 9 0 0
ZDA van Baren c FJ de Lange b GK Nieuwoudt 9 29 2 0
A Jain c TN de Grooth b ST Mulder 17 33 2 0
MA Durrani lbw b PRP Boissevain 0 5 0 0
JD Schoonheim   b A Dutt 55 55 6 3
RR Upadhyaya lbw b A Dutt 24 55 2 0
R Malik c TN de Grooth b PRP Boissevain 0 14 0 0
PJ Fletcher* c M Hingorani b BFW de Leede 16 27 2 0
SB van Wingerden not out   0 2 0 0
BRA Ruyters   b BFW de Leede 0 1 0 0
extras   (b0 lb2 w7 nb1) 10      
TOTAL   10 wickets for 136      
FOW
1-3(MP O’Dowd) 2-7(SA Edwards) 3-19(ZDA van Baren) 4-21(MA Durrani) 5-75(A Jain) 6-105(JD Schoonheim) 7-108(R Malik) 8-136(RR Upadhyaya) 9-136(PJ Fletcher) 10-136(BRA Ruyters)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
BFW de Leede 7.3 1 24 4 5
GK Nieuwoudt 10 2 27 1 1
PRP Boissevain 9 1 33 2
ST Mulder 6 0 30 1 1
A Dutt 8 0 20 2 1
Voorburg I 1st Innings 120/1 (Overs 29.1)
Batter Fielder Bowler Runs Bls 4s 6s
M Hingorani+ not out   39 72 0 0
TN de Grooth   b PJ Fletcher 14 16 2 0
BFW de Leede* not out   57 87 6 0
SA Engelbrecht dnb          
A Dutt dnb          
GK Nieuwoudt dnb          
PRP Boissevain dnb          
VJ Kingma dnb          
FJ de Lange dnb          
ST Mulder dnb          
L Boissevain dnb          
extras   (b0 lb1 w9 nb0) 10      
TOTAL   1 wickets for 120      
FOW
1-15(TN de Grooth)
Bowler Overs Maid Runs Wkts wd nb
PJ Fletcher 7 2 14 1
A Jain 6 0 31 0 1
JD Schoonheim 4 0 21 0 2
ZDA van Baren 3 0 18 0 6
RR Upadhyaya 3 0 10 0
MP O’Dowd 4 0 15 0
SB van Wingerden 1.1 0 8 0
BRA Ruyters 1 0 2 0